Nano Banana Pro vs ChatGPT Image 1.5

With ChatGPT’s newest mannequin taking the world by storm, you could be questioning in regards to the previous guard: Nano Banana Professional. Giving the style {of professional} grade picture era and modifying to all customers, Nano Banana is THE device individuals attain out to, for AI-image era. 

However does this nonetheless maintain true? Will this be the case sooner or later? We’ll discover out on this article, the place we put to check the most recent iterations of ChatGPT Picture and Nano Banana throughout difficult duties, to see which one fares properly. 

What’s GPT Picture 1.5?

ChatGPT Picture 1.5 is the most recent picture era mannequin by OpenAI, constructed to show concepts into visuals with pace and precision. Whether or not somebody is creating from a clean immediate or modifying an current photograph, the mannequin delivers outcomes that carefully match the supposed imaginative and prescient. It helps exact edits whereas preserving advantageous particulars and generates photos as much as 4x quicker than earlier variations.

The mannequin comes with a brand new Pictures expertise inside ChatGPT, that allows easy creation and refinement of photos.

What’s Nano-Banana Professional?

Nano Banana Professional brings a significant improve over the unique Nano Banana, including superior textual content rendering for clear on-image textual content, exact modifying controls for lighting, digital camera angle and facet ratio, crisp 2K decision outputs, improved world information for correct diagrams and infographics, and the flexibility to mix much more images seamlessly. It takes every thing the bottom mannequin was good at and elevates it for skilled, high-quality inventive work.

Learn extra: Nano Banana Professional

Showdown: Let’s Make Some Pictures

These picture era fashions are superior to start with. Testing how properly they make logos and plushies, could be youngster’s play for them, and wouldn’t be an excellent take a look at of their enhanced capabilities. 

Subsequently, I’d be testing these on the next complicated duties:

Activity 1: Multi-Step Picture Enhancing With State Preservation 

What this checks: Whether or not the mannequin can protect scene identification, lighting coherence, and object placement throughout a number of edits. Most fashions degrade or “reset” the picture when edits stack.

I used the next picture as an enter:

Now I’d be progressively making edits on it, and would choose how properly the mannequin preserves the picture’s integrity. 

Change the time of day from Night time to Day.

Change the couch with a Picket couch set.

Alter the digital camera angle to the angle from the open house outdoors. From the glass doorways seen within the picture wanting contained in the room.

Remark:

Nano Banana Professional produced higher outputs as in comparison with ChatGPT Picture 1.5. That is highlighted by the next errors within the ChatGPT response photos:

1. In altering from night time to day, the backdrop of buildings received altered from the unique. 
2. When changing the couch with a Picket couch set, the middle desk’s construction received modified.

Each the fashions failed in producing a half-way convincing picture within the final process.

Right here’s the enjoyable half: The enter picture was made by ChatGPT Picture itself! However nonetheless it ended up underperforming within the duties. 

Activity 2: Dense Instruction Following in a Single Immediate

What this checks: Immediate obedience underneath constraint, textual content rendering accuracy, and compositional planning. Fashions usually get one or two particulars proper and ignore the remaining.

Response:

Remark:

The place Nano Banana Professional made a poster that might be used for selling a tech convention, ChatGPT Picture’s output appears extra like a newbie’s effort at Photoshop. 

Activity 3: Technical Diagram With Actual-World Accuracy

What this checks: World information, diagram logic, spatial reasoning, and legible textual content. That is the place “fairly” fashions fail laborious in the event that they don’t really perceive construction.

Create a labeled infographic explaining how a transformer-based language mannequin processes textual content, together with:
1. Tokenization
2. Consideration layers
3. Embeddings
4. Output chances
All labels have to be readable and positioned accurately.

Response:

Remark:

Each the infographics had their fair proportion of flaws. Nano Banana Professional was nonetheless comparatively higher. The errors had been far and few, the visuals had been on level, and there was an excellent mixture of textual content in it. This made it simpler to undergo. ChatGPT Picture 1.5, took the purely visible route. However contemplating the redundant step (4th one) and unexplained visuals, it’d be laborious for one to wrap their head round what was shared.

Activity 4: Model Consistency Throughout A number of Pictures

What this checks: Character identification persistence and stylistic continuity. This is likely one of the hardest issues in picture era proper now.

Generate a three-image storyboard for a brief movie:
Body 1: Opening scene
Body 2: Battle
Body 3: Decision
The identical character should seem in all three frames with constant facial options, clothes, and proportions, whereas lighting and digital camera angles change.

Response:

Remark:

Right here’s what a Storyboard means:

• a sequence of drawings, sometimes with some instructions and dialogue, representing the pictures deliberate for a movie or tv manufacturing.

Once I had requested for a storyboard, I wished some route both implicitly within the picture or supplemented with it. The ChatGPT Picture 1.5 response crammed every thing in a single picture, which in of itself was bland. 

Nano Banana Professional not solely offered a number of photos that present a route however additional added textual content, which might justify the transition throughout the pictures. Very properly made response. 

Activity 5: Photorealism vs. Artwork Course Tradeoff

What this checks: High-quality-detail rendering, textual content readability, materials realism, and the flexibility to steadiness inventive lighting with industrial accuracy.

Create a product shot of a smartwatch that:
1. Seems to be photorealistic sufficient for an e-commerce website
2. Makes use of dramatic, studio-style lighting
3. Contains engraved textual content on the dial that is still sharp and readable
4. Maintains right reflections and materials properties

Response:

Remark: 

Nano Banana Professional made a picture that likened a sensible watch reveal shot. ChatGPT Picture made some analog-esque watch within the identify of a sensible watch, and as an alternative of the design talking for the smartness, had blatantly added “Smartwatch” throughout the rim of the watch.

Verdict

Right here are some things I had realised whereas utilizing the 2 picture era fashions:

• One factor that was obvious was that Nano Banana Professional is wayyyy quicker than ChatGPT Picture 1.5. This wait time was accentuated when the prompts had been complicated or had been multi-leveled. 
• The Picture interface of ChatGPT could be very buggy. Generally it really works flawlessly, and also you neglect that it’s there. Different instances, it’d be laborious so that you can even get a picture made out of it. The disparity in expertise is astonishing. 
• ChatGPT Picture for what it affords, is restricted to single picture response. From duties 4 it was clear that when the requirement is a number of or multi-level photos, the responses of ChatGPT Picture 1.5 falls flat. Any stage of intricate immediate engineering would’nt make the mannequin spout greater than a single picture. 
  Nano Banana Professional, clearly doesn’t have these constraints. 

With all these at hand, It’d be protected to say that Nano Banana Professional, nonetheless holds that edge which made it mainstream within the first place. The place ChatGPT’s Picture 1.5 presents developments in text-based visuals, its efficiency in different regards leaves quite a bit to be anticipated.

For those who’d prefer to be taught extra about prompting throughout these fashions, you possibly can check out the next articles:

Continuously Requested Questions